Citation

Justice and the Compulsory Taking of Body Parts

Abstract | Word Stems | Keywords | Association | Citation | Get this Document | Similar Titles




STOP!

You can now view the document associated with this citation by clicking on the "View Document as HTML" link below.

View Document as HTML:
Click here to view the document

Abstract:

Thousands of people, throughout the world, are so medically needy that they must get an organ, some tissue or blood in order to lead minimally decent lives or even to survive; the majority of them will not get a transplant, and some of them will die as a result. This paper argues that, if one thinks that the needy have a right to the material resources they need to lead minimally decent lives, one must be committed, in some cases, to conferring on the sick a right that the healthy give them some of the body parts they need to lead such a life. My argument proceeds in two steps: first, I show that body parts are the kind of resources of which it makes sense to say that one can have a right to it; second, I show that the very considerations that dictate conferring welfare rights on the poor dictate conferring on the sick rights to some of the body parts of the healthy.
I then assess two objections against that view, to wit: to confer on the sick a right to the live body parts of the healthy (a) violates the bodily integrity of the latter; and (b) constitutes too much of an interference in their life. The first one relies on a misinterpretation of the Kantian requirement that people be treated as ends; the second one relies too heavily on the principles of acts and omissions and double-effect. However, although those objections are not as strong as their proponents aver, they lead me to qualify my proposal in some respects. I conclude that although the sick sometimes have a right to some of the body parts of the healthy, the latter still retain a considerable degree of autonomy.

Most Common Document Word Stems:

bodi (166), part (138), one (102), right (95), would (92), life (85), need (74), duti (67), healthi (58), decent (54), resourc (52), sick (49), person (47), lead (45), someon (44), help (44), claim (44), moral (42), transfer (40), individu (39), case (38),

Author's Keywords:

Keywords: justice; autonomy; rights; bodily integrity; sufficiency; organ taking
Convention
Need a solution for abstract management? All Academic can help! Contact us today to find out how our system can help your annual meeting.
Submission - Custom fields, multiple submission types, tracks, audio visual, multiple upload formats, automatic conversion to pdf.Review - Peer Review, Bulk reviewer assignment, bulk emails, ranking, z-score statistics, and multiple worksheets!
Reports - Many standard and custom reports generated while you wait. Print programs with participant indexes, event grids, and more!Scheduling - Flexible and convenient grid scheduling within rooms and buildings. Conflict checking and advanced filtering.
Communication - Bulk email tools to help your administrators send reminders and responses. Use form letters, a message center, and much more!Management - Search tools, duplicate people management, editing tools, submission transfers, many tools to manage a variety of conference management headaches!
Click here for more information.

Association:
Name: American Political Science Association
URL:
http://www.apsanet.org


Citation:
URL: http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p64997_index.html
Direct Link:
HTML Code:

MLA Citation:

Fabre, Cecile. "Justice and the Compulsory Taking of Body Parts" Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Boston Marriott Copley Place, Sheraton Boston & Hynes Convention Center, Boston, Massachusetts, Aug 28, 2002 <Not Available>. 2009-05-27 <http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p64997_index.html>

APA Citation:

Fabre, C. , 2002-08-28 "Justice and the Compulsory Taking of Body Parts" Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Boston Marriott Copley Place, Sheraton Boston & Hynes Convention Center, Boston, Massachusetts Online <.PDF>. 2009-05-27 from http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p64997_index.html

Publication Type: Conference Paper/Unpublished Manuscript
Review Method: Peer Reviewed
Abstract: Thousands of people, throughout the world, are so medically needy that they must get an organ, some tissue or blood in order to lead minimally decent lives or even to survive; the majority of them will not get a transplant, and some of them will die as a result. This paper argues that, if one thinks that the needy have a right to the material resources they need to lead minimally decent lives, one must be committed, in some cases, to conferring on the sick a right that the healthy give them some of the body parts they need to lead such a life. My argument proceeds in two steps: first, I show that body parts are the kind of resources of which it makes sense to say that one can have a right to it; second, I show that the very considerations that dictate conferring welfare rights on the poor dictate conferring on the sick rights to some of the body parts of the healthy.
I then assess two objections against that view, to wit: to confer on the sick a right to the live body parts of the healthy (a) violates the bodily integrity of the latter; and (b) constitutes too much of an interference in their life. The first one relies on a misinterpretation of the Kantian requirement that people be treated as ends; the second one relies too heavily on the principles of acts and omissions and double-effect. However, although those objections are not as strong as their proponents aver, they lead me to qualify my proposal in some respects. I conclude that although the sick sometimes have a right to some of the body parts of the healthy, the latter still retain a considerable degree of autonomy.

Get this Document:

Find this citation or document at one or all of these locations below. The links below may have the citation or the entire document for free or you may purchase access to the document. Clicking on these links will change the site you're on and empty your shopping cart.

Abstract Only All Academic Inc.
Associated Document Available American Political Science Association
Associated Document Available Political Research Online

Document Type: .pdf
Page count: 18
Word count: 12760
Text sample:
1 Justice and the Compulsory Taking of Live Body Parts CÉCILE FABRE London School of Economics Prepared for delivery at the 2002 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association August29­September 1 2002. Copyright by the American Political Science Association. 2 I. INTRODUCTION Consider the following two scenarios: 1. Ann has been taken ill to hospital. If she does not get medicine for which through no fault of her own she cannot afford to pay she will lead a
hold out the hope of cure for diabetics' The Guardian January 27 2001. For a very good account of the permissibility of risk imposition see J. J. Thomson `Imposing Risks' in her Rights Restitution and Risks Cambridge Mass. 1986. 27 Versions of this paper were presented at various seminar (Bristol Essex London Louvain­la­Neuve Montreal and Nuffield College Oxford) whose participants I thank here for a number of useful suggestions. I am particularly grateful to D. Butt M. Cohen ­Christofidis


Similar Titles:
Healthy Relationships: How Changes to the Current Structure of Healthcare in America would Help Individuals Achieve Gender Equity in Marriage

The Right to Work as Part of Universal Human Rights- Is the Right to Work/the Decent Work Agenda Universal From the Perspective of Human Rights Politics?


 
All Academic, Inc. is your premier source for research and conference management. Visit our website, www.allacademic.com, to see how we can help you today.